A crack that leaks after rain should be treated as both a water issue and an evidence point. The crack is where water is visible, but the cause may include exterior water pressure, poor drainage, a failed footing drain, shrinkage, settlement, or wall movement.
Some leaking cracks can be sealed with polyurethane or epoxy injection. Others need exterior repair, drainage correction, or structural evaluation. The difference depends on whether the crack is stable, active, widening, horizontal, stair-stepped, or paired with wall movement.
The safest way to compare estimates is to ask what the contractor believes caused the crack to leak and what the proposed repair does if water pressure returns.
Document crack direction, width, location, and change. A vertical crack that leaks only during heavy rain is different from a horizontal crack in a bowing wall. A crack that was patched before and leaks again is also important because it may mean water pressure was never addressed.
